Samsung nailed folding screens. Don’t expect Apple to follow

The tech has been 20 years in the making, and, with the Z Flip, it's finally here. But where is it going next?

Samsungs folding screens
Samsungs folding screens

Samsung’s Galaxy Z Flip is the very shiniest folding phone that a not-insignificant chunk of cash can buy, and the only one to have real glass in its screen.


And now, Samsung’s set about commercialising its Ultra-Thin Glass (UTG) technology.

The Z Flip display’s ultra-thin glass was a major marketing point for Samsung, but as the phones made their way into the hands of disassemblers, it rapidly became apparent that the 30 micron (micrometre; μm) layer of UTG isn’t the only thing covering the flexible AMOLED.

Tear-downs have shown that there’s plastic on top and glass, which can be cracked and shattered with enough abuse, with the digitiser and AMOLED display below that.

Samsung has clearly learned from the troubled 2019 launch of the Galaxy Fold and done a good job of managing user expectations this time around. The Galaxy Z Flip is clearly marketed as a niche vanity phone – a cool-looking one at that – for people with an express interest in carrying the bleeding edge of smartphone tech around with them.

Both on its packaging and the first time you power it up, the phone tells you that you should avoid pressing hard on the screen to keep it safe, avoid trapping or sticking anything against the screen, and that it’s not dust-proof, although a few more warnings about all this on Samsung’s purchase page wouldn’t hurt.

Speaking to The Verge, Samsung confirmed the existence of a “protective layer on top of the UTG similar to Galaxy Fold” and says that the intention is to deliver a “sleek, premium look and offer an immersive viewing experience”.

But that plastic layer can be scratched and burned as easily as the surface of a polyimide display. So what’s the point of having a glass screen if you’re going to slap a layer of plastic on top of it?

Design and innovation consultant Matthew Cockerill says that “the glass screen certainly improves the look and touch experience,” which we also found when using the sharp, bright screen.

He notes that our expectations of what a smartphone should feel like and how we interact with it have been formed by modern glass screens: we anticipate a rigid surface to push against and for fingertips to glide with less friction than you’ll generally get from even the most sophisticated plastics.

Jo Barnard, founder of industrial design studio Morrama, says that, although glass is preferable over plastic for the optical properties and the scratch resistance at just 30 microns thick, a plastic layer is necessary to protect ultra-thin glass of this kind, where “a single scratch can turn into a huge crack”.

“For the people up in arms about it not being fully glass,” she adds, “did you really think it would be?”

The processes of making glass that’s thin and flexible enough to fold almost in half are closely guarded. However, we do know that Samsung is working with German glass and ceramics technology group Schott AG, who “can confirm that we deliver SCHOTT ultra-thin glass (UTG) to Samsung” but “cannot comment on any processing details of the raw glass material or the display technology itself”.

Schott holds and has applied for some notable patents for chemically strengthened ultra-thin glass, as well as for polymer coatings to strengthen them, detailing “displays, consisting of a glass film which is between 10 μm and 500 μm thick, and a polymer layer with a thickness between 1 μm and 200 μm applied to at least one of its side faces.”

The company has published some very basic mechanical details of its down-draw manufacturing process for glass as little as 30 microns thick.

Back at home, although Samsung confirmed that it has “never named the other Korean company with which we are commercialising the UTG,” a likely option for the identity of that company is Dowoo Insys, in which Samsung Display became the largest shareholder in December 2019, with Korea’s major Maeil Business News reporting Samsung Display as saying that the purchase was for “investment purposes for its foldable phone business”.

Dowoo Insys holds a number of South Korean patents for manufacturing toughened glass for mobile devices, including a particularly interesting 2016 patent for a ‘Flexural Strength Improving Method for Glass’ so that “the ultra-thin glass of 100㎛ or less can be used as the window glass of foldable devices”.

This involves multiple stages including chemical- and heat-treating the glass to eventually improve flexural strength 1,000 per cent, allowing a curvature radius of 2mm – close enough to a flat fold for the purposes of a well-designed smartphone. This kind of almost-but-not-quite flat fold is typical of current ultra-thin glass technology.

Meanwhile, Samsung’s patents also include details of a “protection film”, reinforced along the fold line, that could be applied to “a flexible glass substrate, a flexible polymer substrate, or a combination thereof”. More